Negligence or suicide?

The Record on NorthJersey.com had an article about the trial between the family of a resident who fell to his death from a window left open on the second floor at Preakness Healthcare Center.

“Simply put, as a result of their negligence, he suffered 23 days of hell,” said attorney Angelo Bisceglie, referring to Ora Tate  Tate had been admitted to Preakness by his sister, Loretta Tinsley, on July 3, 2006. He was found by a construction worker at about 7:30 a.m. lying 16 feet below his second-floor room window on July 28, 2006. Pulmonary problems and injuries led to his death three weeks later.

Bisceglie said it was unfortunate that Tate’s room had what is known as an “awning window,” which a person of average size could fall out of as Tate did.

Preakness staffers should have known that Tate might harm himself, given his psychological condition, and been placed in a room that would have been safer.

 

Neglect and failure to supervise leads to wanderer's death

The Buffalo News had a story about 3 nursing home employees who were only disciplined when the employees did not check on a resident or failed to report him missing for over 11 hours.  The Health Department found that the employees, over an 11-hour period, each noticed that Trent Lockridge was not in his room but did not report it.  The resident either fell, was pushed, or jumped from his second-floor room in Dosberg Manor on the night of Feb. 17, but his body was not found until the next morning.

The Health Department required that the facility discipline the employees involved, put in place new policies for ensuring the whereabouts of all residents and train its employees in the new system.

Health Department investigators visited Dosberg Manor after Lockridge’s death, interviewing staff members and reviewing facility records. Their report found that the first employee had responded to a Feb. 17 call from Lockridge’s roommate requesting help in closing the window. The employee noted that the window was wide open, Lockridge’s glasses were on the nightstand, and his walker was near the window. She neither investigated the fact that he was not in the room nor told anyone about it.  In fact, when first questioned by department investigators, she lied and told them that she had seen Lockridge in his room at 9:40 p.m. She later confessed to a co-worker that this was not the case, the report states.

The second employee, who went into the room at 11 p. m. as part of a daily census of residents, assumed that Lockridge had been hospitalized but did not follow up on this or attempt to confirm it.

The third employee, who was assigned to Lockridge’s floor, stopped by the room at midnight as part of her rounds and also noticed that Lockridge was not in his bed, according to the report. Further, Lockridge’s medical records reflected that staff had helped him take a dose of medicine at 6:30 a. m. Feb. 18, when he was still missing. He was not reported missing until 6:45 a. m., when a nurse said she couldn’t find him. His body had been outside for at least 11 hours in freezing temperatures.

The report concludes that the employees should have notified a supervisor when they saw that Lockridge was missing and that the window was open. It does not name them.  Neither the Weinberg Campus nor the Health Department would say what disciplinary action was taken. Weinberg has agreed to put in place a new system for keeping track of Dosberg Manor residents and to train employees in the new procedures.

 

Poliakoff & Associates, P.A., is one of South Carolina’s most respected and distinguished law firms. The Poliakoff firm began nearly 60 years ago by three attorney brothers: Matthew, J. Manning, and Bernard. With a history of believing the justice system...More...